|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Assessing
Historical Sources
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
top
|
DISCIPLINE
History
DURATION
Entire length of subject/unit/course(24 weeks of 1 hour per
week).
ICT USED
CD-ROM
DELIVERY CONTEXT
Mixed mode: Optional face-to-face for external students through
an optional residential school; compulsory face-to-face with
internal students through lectures and tutorial; optional
online discussion groups for external (and internal) students;
printed Study Guide and Resource Materials; CD-ROM.
TARGET AUDIENCE
First year undergraduate history students with varying levels
of prior knowledge and experience, of varying ages (school
entry and mature age), and a mixture of on-campus and distance
education students.
COHORT
Originally designed to accommodate increasing enrolments (from
50 to over 200). Able to accommodate more than the number
enrolled.
BROADER CONTEXT
Sources for Courses provides an essential grounding
in ways to identify, reference, read and evaluate historical
sources. The content focuses on Australian history, the skills
have a far broader application. To this end, the learning
design provides an important part of first year undergraduate
introductions to history. The template could be adapted and
used with other course content (e.g. late modern European history,
world history). The emphasis on introducing and/or improving
essential skills provides a foundation for other learning
tasks in the unit: short written exercises, tutorial presentations,
formal essays, class discussion.
The emphasis on the variety of sources, approaches to, and
uses of history is also important in establishing the types
of work in which historians of the 21st century are engaged.
Through Sources for Courses students become aware
of museums, historic sites, landscape, film, novels as providing
both sources for understanding history and different ways
of presenting history.
|
top
|
History research is underpinned by an understanding of the
differences between primary and secondary sources, and of
the layers of meaning which can be discerned in different
types of sources. Sources for Courses aims to assist
students to improve their skills in identifying, referencing,
interpreting, analysing and using a variety of historical
sources.
Sources for Courses also intends to improve students'
written communication skills, especially their ability to
write concisely and analytically about the messages and uses
of different historical sources.
|
top
|
IMPLEMENTATION OF ASSESSMENT STRATEGIES
Currently, the key assessment strategy requires students to
submit examples of written annotations of selected sources
at different stages of the unit. It is an individual assessment
which is assessed against the following criteria (the criteria
are included as part of the study materials):
- Clear explanation of why the source is a primary or secondary
source.
- Afocused and short summary of the contents and arguments
contained in the source .
- An evaluation of the strengths and weaknesses of the source,
and of how the particular source has contributed to the
student’s understanding of the specific topic.
- Clear and grammatically correct expression.
- Accurate and consistent bibliographical details.
IMPORTANCE OF ASSESSMENT STRATEGIES USED
The annotated sources assessment tasks assist students to
develop skills in identifying, referencing, 'reading', discussing,
analysing and writing about different types of sources. These
are essential skills in history and also contribute towards
the development of specific generic attributes of University
of New England graduates in the areas of communication skills,
information literacy, life-long learning and problem solving.
They are also skills which are essential for a variety of
other learning activities and assessment tasks including,
for example, researching and writing formal essays, developing
research proposals, writing well substantiated reports, and
preparing analytical seminar presentations.
|
top
|
WHY ICT IS USED
The approach and design of the database evolved as a response
to difficulties among first year undergraduate students in
history to access and read a variety of sources, to understand
the messages in them, to appreciate the various ways in which
the sources are interpreted by historians, and to summarise
their critical reading and thinking concisely and in a focused
way. It also evolved in response to the need to provide students
with the time and resources to become familiar with these
sources and the issues involved in using them for historical
research and writing at their own pace and in independent
learning environments.
The variety of resources and learning tasks imbedded in the
database mean that students can locate the same source in
a variety of contexts and with a variety of readings. They
can then build on the examples provided to identify and read
other, similar sources. They can also view sources or parts
of sources, they can become familiar with the ways of referencing
different types of sources, and they can do a great deal of
their learning at home or in a private study environment.
HOW ICT USE HELPS
The multimedia capabilities of the database on CD-ROM provide
the means to offer a far wider range and diversity of sources:
there are printed documents, and there are images, sound,
film clips, etc.
The storage capabilities enable the provision of a far larger
amount of material (sources, reading guides, topic guides
and exercises etc) than is financially viable through printed
resources. The ability to update and add to the database relatively
easily also make it more viable than printed material.
CD-Rom is more appropriate than the other obvious ICT online
format. Not all students have unlimited time access to the
computer facilities required to spend time browsing and using
the database. The cross-platform CD-ROM is more accessible.
The relational features of the database remove the forced
linear format of printed materials. On the CD-ROM students
can move across and between topics, sources, types of sources,
and seek out different combinations. It invites a more imaginative
approach on the part of both students and lecturers.
MOST IMPORTANT ICT CONTRIBUTION TO LEARNING DESIGN
The most important aspect of using ICT is the ability to include
a variety of media, to mix and match between databases, to
provide readily portable material which can be accessed in
private study environments. Also, the ability to update and
add to material relatively easily and in a cost effective
way.
|
top
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|